Friday, July 23, 2010

Why I don't Want to Live in Britain

I rather think that I have to – with some reluctance – describe myself as ‘antimulticultural’. Travelling the world as a fly on the wall allows exposure to a number of different cultural identities. Here in France, the sense of identity is firm and well-developed but in Britain, this is far less in evidence. Having been born and brought up there, one reason why I left was that I had less and less idea what it meant to be ‘British’ any more. Multiculturalism is a moral vacuum, and “into a moral vacuum always bad things creep.” Of course, I felt guilty, because pluralism or multiracial societies seem to me to be good and desirable things – learning from others, and so on - but a multicultural society where group differences are actually encouraged, especially when such differences are in moral, spiritual or even legal conflict, seems to me to be a very bad thing. It leads to a defensive, ghetto mentality which, if threatened, spills over into antisocial behaviour, or worse, defence of the prevalent mentality in the ghetto which spawned it. According to Douglas Murray, Director of the Centre for Social Cohesion, a London-based think tank, the problem is “that the British government has pushed young Muslims into becoming young Muslims when it should have pushed them into becoming young Brits. In other words, the direction of travel it sent them in has been deeply backward.”
British Muslims might ask ‘You tell me to integrate, but what are we integrating into? What is Britain, what are British values?’ It’s very hard to tell people to integrate if you don’t tell them what they are integrating into. It’s very hard to tell them to be British if they don’t know and you don’t know what Britishness is. The fact is that we have been very poor in saying what we are and we have also been very poor is saying what we expect people to be. We’ve been very good in stressing what rights people get when they come to Britain and very bad at explaining what responsibilities come with them. Once so-called multicultural societies decided that they didn’t have a locus, that they didn’t have a centre of gravity, anyone could ride in and teach the most pernicious things,” Murray goes on. “It didn’t matter. It was just another point of view.
Saul Bellow once wrote “When public morality becomes a ghost town, it’s a place into which anyone can ride and declare himself sheriff.”


  1. I don't want to live in Britain. =) Funnily enough, I don't want to live in the Caribbean either.

  2. i like the encouragement of difference - the chaos is often painful but formative. Indeed, it may be the solution to an existing moral vacuum. would we still have slavery were it not for the development and acknowledgement of the validity of others approach to life i.e. a multicultural society.

    For the individual, one of the questions that help to resolve what one thinks of the society is: where do you want to spend your last days and why? The answer, because it presupposes a time of vunerability, leads to a clearer idea of what you think you are intergrating to. If not your "own people" then the pain of change is perhaps too powerful for you.

  3. AD makes a telling point - thank you, and one which in more private times I have given more than a little thought to. The luxury of choice is denied to many, however. As to the formative and painful - I am reminded of Socrates "The just and the unjust, the beautiful and the ugly, the good and the bad. Are these not the subjects of difference about which, when we are unable to come to a satisfactory decision, you and I and other men become hostile to each other whenever we do?"

  4. DM - I think you're just being fussy, but if the idea of a climate so cold that your nose gets gangrene from frostbite is appealing, then you're a lot tougher than i thought.

  5. I have no desire to live where I gangrene of the nose. Ugh!! Slowly, we're eliminating all the places we don't want to live. lol

    And since when is fussy a bad thing? Where are you by the way?


Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.